Playbooks
Playbook Page
New Relic

How New Relic’s VP of Product Marketing, Pallavi Vanacharla, Positions New Products in Competitive Markets

Pallavi VanacharlaPallavi Vanacharla
New Relic VP, Product Marketing, Formerly Cisco Jasper (Cisco IoT)
Summary

In this playbook, I will reveal the best competitive positioning approach I have used to-date. The quantitative analysis framework used within this approach was developed by myself and my peers (Theresa Bui and Sanjay Khatri) at a previous company — Cisco. 


Cisco Jasper was a leading Internet of Things (IoT) platform that offered a cloud-based solution for managing and connecting IoT devices. Cisco Jasper played a crucial role in the IoT industry, providing enterprises and service providers with a scalable and efficient solution to monitor, control, and analyze connected devices. 


In 2017, Cisco Jasper launched a product as a new entrant into an existing market with several established competitors. In this playbook, I will explain how that positioning model works, and how we used it to position that product — the Enterprise Mobility Platform — for managing employee mobile devices and services. 

Who this is for:

This playbook is designed for product marketing professionals who need to position a new or existing product in a highly competitive market and are seeking a more structured and analytical approach to positioning.


What you will learn:

  1. A step-by-step process of product positioning

  2. The scientific and artistic aspects of crafting positioning

  3. How to ensure your positioning is compelling

  4. How to position quickly when in a time crunch

Table of Contents:

Context

About Cisco Jasper (Cisco IoT)

Goals

Framework

5-Step Process to Position a New Product in a Competitive Market

Diagram: 5-Step Process to Position a New Product in a Competitive Market

Case Study

0. Pre-work: Go-To-Market (GTM) Strategy 

Diagram: Pre-work: Go-To-Market (GTM) Strategy

1. Gather Customers’ Decision Criteria

Define Customer Interview Scope

Figuring Out to the Right Titles

Conducting a LinkedIn Campaign

Mapping the Buyer Personas

Building the Positioning Worksheet

🔥 Hot Tip 1: Value vs. Criteria

🔥 Hot Tip 2: Segment Responses for Targeted Positioning

🔥 Hot Tip 3: Less is More

2. Identify the Right Competitive Set

Identifying the Competitors

Defining the Competitive Capabilities

Identifying Market Trends

🔥 Hot Tip 1: Alternatives vs. Competitors

🔥 Hot Tip 2: Positioning Shelf Life

3. Evaluate the Competitors

Rating the Competitors

Bringing Positioning All Together

Diagram: Competitive Advantage

🔥 Hot Tip: Understand Legal Boundaries

4. Build the Positioning Matrix with Stakeholders

Essential stakeholders

Understanding the Positioning Matrix

Brainstorming Positioning Matrix Dimensions

Feedback from Customers, Sales, and Analysts

Seeking Consensus and Sign-off

🔥 Hot Tip: Unlock Success Through Collaborative Alignment

5. Craft the Positioning Statement

Adapting Geoffrey Moore’s Framework

Diagram: Positioning Statement Template

Our Positioning Statement

Building a Sense of Ownership

🔥 Hot Tip 1: Time-crunch Positioning

🔥 Hot Tip 2: Positioning Refresh

6. Measuring Success

Wrap Up – Key Insights 

Playbook Content

Context

About Cisco Jasper (Cisco IoT)

Cisco Jasper was a leading Internet of Things (IoT) platform that offered a cloud-based solution for managing and connecting IoT devices. Cisco Jasper played a crucial role in the IoT industry, providing enterprises and service providers with a scalable and efficient solution to monitor, control, and analyze connected devices. 


In 2017, Cisco Jasper introduced a new solution, Cisco Enterprise Mobility Platform — catering to those needing a streamlined solution to manage employee mobile devices and services. With an increasing number of organizations adopting mobile technologies for their workforce, the market presented significant opportunities. 


To seize these opportunities, we recognized the importance of crafting precise and customer-centric positioning to effectively communicate the value of our product to potential customers. But we were entering a crowded and highly competitive market. And so we faced the critical challenge of establishing a unique and compelling positioning strategy to differentiate ourselves in the market.

Goals

As with any product positioning, our goal was to capture a space in the customer’s mind that a) could meet their unmet needs, b) was uniquely differentiated, c) would drive a preference for our solution and d) would be sustainable for at least a few years.  


If you have dabbled with positioning or read anything about it, you know positioning is what the customer thinks of your product/solution in their mind. And so, naturally, the success of your product’s positioning can really only be determined well after the product launch — Do customers talk about your product the way that you thought they would? 


Please keep that in mind as you think about the timeframe for measuring your success. 

Framework


The framework we built analyzes 1) what purchasing criteria customers use, 2) what product and business strengths aim to meet those, and 3) how competitors rank against it all. The framework includes a simple worksheet that synthesizes all of this information: 


This worksheet, when completed, creates a strengths and weaknesses comparison chart that helps to ground everyone in a common understanding of the current market reality. And it provided a clear direction on the vectors that should be considered for effective positioning of the offering. The worksheet could easily be easily edited to adapt to product changes and market dynamics, allowing us to remain relevant over the long term as well. 

  • In my opinion, for most products, positioning should be revised at least once every year, and messaging should be revised ideally every quarter.


This worksheet was only one piece of the puzzle. The positioning process itself was, and is, a bit more comprehensive.  

5-Step Process to Position a New Product in a Competitive Market

Our product positioning process followed five key steps:

  1. Gather customers’ decision criteria: Conduct in-depth interviews with customers. Understand their pain points, goals, preferences, and most importantly, their decision criteria, as critical inputs into the positioning exercise..

  2. Identify the right competitive set: Analyze competitors' products, market trends, and business capabilities to define the competitive set to evaluate competitors on. 

  3. Evaluate the competitors: Analyze the competitors against the above competitive set to gain a clear understanding of each competitor’s strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities for market differentiation. 

  4. Build the positioning matrix with stakeholders: Build the positioning matrix that highlights the product’s core differentiated strengths, and seek the diverse perspectives of key stakeholders to ensure alignment and clarity.

  5. Craft the Positioning Statement: Craft a compelling positioning statement that resonates with the target audience and effectively sets the company apart from competitors.

Diagram: 5-Step Process to Position a New Product in a Competitive Market

Read the rest of this playbook with a free Sharebird account.
Sharebird is free to join. By continuing, you agree that you are at least 13 years old and agree to our terms of service and privacy policy.
Sharebird is where executives at top companies share their expertise.
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Companies
Popular Playbooks
HubSpot
How HubSpot's Product Marketing Team Refreshes Messaging To Improve Sales Win Rates
Unity
How Unity VP of Product Marketing, Jon Rooney, Validates Messaging To Hit Product Launch Stretch Goals
Calendly
How Calendly's Product Marketing Team Successfully Launched an Enterprise Offering